Writer: Gail Simone
Art: Luciano Vecchio, Rachelle Rosenberg, MAtthew Wilson, VC’s Clayton Cowles, and David Marquez
LUCIANO VECCHIO (A) • Cover by DAVID MARQUEZ
Publisher: Marvel Comics
Price: $4.99
Reviewed by: Anonymous
Release Date: July 23rd, 2025
For the first time in New Orleans history, the city has declared a MUTANT APPRECIATION DAY festival and street fair, with all the music, food and fun the city is famous for. If the Hellfire Gala is filet mignon, this is corn dogs and lemonade. But are all mutants okay with this attempt at bridging the gap, or are sinister forces lurking behind the Tilt-A-Whirl?
If you’re interested in this comic, series, related trades, or any of the others mentioned, then simply click on the title/link to snag a copy through Amazon as you read the Uncanny X-Men #18 Review.
THE DISPATCH
Uncanny X‑Men #18 brings the setting to life with a sense of celebration and unease. This “filet mignon vs. corn dog” analogy emphasizes the contrast between the high-society Hellfire Gala and this grassroots attempt to connect with everyday humans. Simone digs into genuine dialogue—some mutants relish the bridge-building, while others remain skeptical. The potential for hidden threats turns what should be fun into suspense—perfect for both character moments and intrigue.
Luciano Vecchio captures the vibrant, carnival atmosphere beautifully: colorful booths, bustling crowds, and festive lighting. Matthew Wilson enhances the mood with warm hues and atmospheric shading that evoke a humid evening. It’s a laid-back, heartfelt environment that Simone punctures with slivers of tension—each Tilt-A-Whirl panel could harbor deeper menace.
Simone leans into the evolving dynamics of her flagship team. Moreover, Rogue and Gambit are charming hosts, but their personal bonds are tested under festival stress if that’s something you’re into. Nightcrawler and Jubilee react differently—one hopeful, the other more wary—highlighting internal X-team divides. Plus, the potential new mutants play into the carnival, some friendly, others clearly hiding agendas play a minor factor as well if that’s your cup of tea.
The Carnival atmosphere gives the series a unique, festive mood. Moroever, the character depth with Simone’s cast feels alive—their hopes and suspicions audible. Plus, the Festival fun hides potent drama, making each scene feel layered. And if the menace behind the Tilt-A-Whirl takes too long to surface, the pacing may drag. However, maintaining both comedic joy and hidden threat requires a deft hand—Simone’s got the skills, but surprises must land as intended.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Uncanny X‑Men #18 is a charming and atmospheric detour that doubles as social commentary and intrigue. Simone’s narrative flair shines as she navigates celebratory energy, character nuance, and suspense. If the evil beneath the festival escalates without overshadowing the emotional beats, this novel chapter could prove one of the X-Men’s most memorable.